Bound in Books: The Baumann Family Story Lives On
by Phyllis Zeck
In 2013 I wrote a post about my mother-in-law, Yvonne Porche Zeck’s ancestry. It’s been awhile since I’ve been back to research her family tree and in the past 10 years I’ve acquired many photos and contacts from the Baumann branch. The two books above have peaked my desire to revisit this family.
The book “Lost Boundaries” by W.L. White tells the story of The Johnston family. Dr Albert Chandler Johnston Jr. was a respected physician who was rejected by the Navy early in WW II because he had African American ancestry. Albert’s wife was Thyra Agatha Baumann. Albert decided it was time to tell his oldest son their family secret, that they were all African American passing as white. Our family connection to Thyra is below. Alma Pauline Harrison (Yvonne’s mother) is Thyra’s first cousin. Thyra and Alma’s grandparents are James Connor Baumann and Matilda Johnson. Thyra and Albert had 4 children: Albert Jr (1926), Donald (1929), Ann (1931) and Paul (1935). The story was made into a movie in 1949 that you can stream titled Lost Boundaries.
Click the image below to enlarge the family tree.
_____________________________________________________________________________
LUCY DAVIS
To better understand Thyra and Alma’s heritage I started with Matilda Johnson’s mother, Lucy Davis. Born about 1822 in Virginia (or North Carolina), she died 21 Jul 1900 in New Orleans. Matilda’s father is assumed to be Richard Johnson born Jan 1823 in Kentucky. I have no documents to back this up, therefore this is as far back as I can trace Matilda’s ancestors. Another brick wall…
Click here for the 1870 Census for Lucy starting on page 1 line 36 and continuing on page 2. This census is taken in Kenner, county of Jefferson, Louisiana. Lucy Davis age 49 is listed as Black and her occupation is a servant and she was born in North Carolina. Samuel Baumann is the head of the family at age 50 and his wife Barbara is 55. James is aged 22 and a grocer, Matilda (8), Pauline (2), Leilia (3). Everyone else’s race is listed as White.
Click here to view the New Orleans 1880 Census (line 20) for Lucy Johnson, age 60. She is living alone. Her birthplace is recorded as Virginia. Both of her parents were born in Virginia. I would assume that this birth place is correct since anyone could have filled in the blanks for the census taker in 1870 and guessed at Lucy’s birth place. Race: Black, Occupation: Keeping House and marital status: Widowed. Her address is 183 W 7th between David St and Patrick St. Click here to download Lucy Davis’ family tree descendant Lucy Davis Descendant Report report.
_____________________________________________________________________________
MATILDA JOHNSON BAUMANN (Lucy’s daughter)
The image to the left is: Kathleen Kennedy born 1915 (daughter of Daisy), Bertha, James, Daisy Baumann and Oliver Randolph (Bertha’s husband). Matilda Johnson Baumann died 7 Apr 1922.
Matilda Johnson (1852-1922) and James Connor Baumann (1848-1928) had the following children: Leila (1867), Pauline Barbara (1869), Josephine Cornelia Amelia (1871), Louisa Marie (1873), Abriam James (1875), Samuel Connor (1876), Rosa (1879), Albert C. (1881), Bertha (1884) and Daisy Juliette (1888).
In the 1870 census Samuel Baumann is the head of the family at age 50 and his wife Barbara is 55. James is aged 22 and a grocer, Matilda (8-this is incorrect), Pauline (2), Leilia (3). Everyone’s race is listed as White. Also on the census is Lucy Davis age 49 and listed as Black and her occupation is a servant.
Click here for the 1880 Census which shows (mid page) Matilda’s occupation: housekeeper, marital status: single, relation to head of house: wife.
To the left is a photo taken about 1890 of James & Matilda with some of their daughters. Click here for the 14 Jun 1888 marriage story of Matilda Johnson and James Connor, written by James Connor. They were married in Jefferson Parish, LA by Rev L.J. Kennedy. It was legal for a white man to marry a mulatto woman in New Orleans in 1888. There was a brief period (1868-1894) when Louisiana’s interracial marriage bans were suspended. In 1910 the state criminalized interracial cohabitation as a felony. The bans remained until the US Supreme Court overturned them in 1967.
Below is a 4 generation photo taken about 1913. Left to right: Pauline Barbara and her daughter Beulah Aloysius (Alma’s sister), Pauline’s mother Matilda and Beulah’s son John Franklin White Jr.
_____________________________________________________________________________
THYRA AGATHA BAUMANN JOHNSTON (Lucy’s great granddaughter)

The 1910 census for Thrya (age 6) lists her race as Mulatto and had an address at 720 Lyon St. in New Orleans. Thrya was living with her grandparents James (61) and Matilda (58) along with their daughter Daisy (21). Also in the home is their son Samuel (34), Samuel’s wife Nettie (Antoinette Juanita Plough 32) and Samuel and Nettie’s children: Clytie (10), Samuel C. Jr (9) and Thyra (7). All are listed Mulatto except James. Click here to view the census. In the 1940 census the families race is recorded as White. The photo to the left is Thrya’s mother Antoinette Plough.
The 1950 census for Thyra (age 46) lists her race as Black. She was living at 146 Washington in Keene, New Hampshire and with her husband Dr. Albert C (age 49 race Black), and their children Albert C Jr, and Ann. Albert was a physician in a hospital. Click here to review the census, lines 2-5. The photo to the left is Thyra’s father Samuel Connor Baumann.
The book referred to above “Lost Boundaries” was published in 1947. It focused on Thyra and Dr Albert’s son Albert who was 16 at the time and the complicated feelings that he struggled with in the next few years as he came to terms with his heritage. The book is out of publication now. The photo below is Thyra & Albert’s family.

_____________________________________________________________________________
JAMES CONNOR BAUMANN (Thyra’s grandfather)
James Connor Baumann was born 27 April 1848 crossing the Atlantic Ocean on the ship “James Corner”. James was appointed in 1870 as Kennerville’s School Director, in 1880 he was mayor of Kenner and by 1886 was a clerk of the 26th Judicial Court in Kennerville. He was nominated to be a Justice of the Peace at the Republican convention soon after.
In the 1900 census (lines 7-16) the family was living at 720 Lyons St in New Orleans, county of Orleans in Louisiana. James is 52 and the record states that he has been married to Matilda since 1868. There is no record for this ceremony. The family are all listed as White including James’ granddaughter Clytie.
This newspaper article from 1891 reports that James Baumann was shot at as he answered his front door of his Kenner home. The family would move to New Orleans the next day.
The photo to the left is the home of Matilda and James listed in the 1895 city directory at 720 Lyons St, New Orleans. On 25 September 1892 James was arrested for instigating the attempted assassination of Judge Long. He was later cleared of the charges.
In my correspondence with family members I’ve conversed with Leslie. Her grandmother Violet and Alma were sisters. She mentioned that a family member donated James Connor Baumann’s scrapbook and family papers to the Newberry Library in Chicago. They have not yet been digitized but I’ll keep watching for them. Maybe my next trip to Chicago will include a trip to the Newberry. I’ve always wanted to pop in there.
James’ scrapbook and family papers were the research used by author Craig Bauer for the excerpts found in his book “An Untractable Country The History of Kenner”.
__________________________________________________________________________
SAMUEL BAUMANN SR. & MARIA BARBARA SCHIBLI PETERHANS
(Thyra’s great grandparents)
Click here for in-depth family tree for Baumann Family dating back to 1492. This was documented by Robert Max Baumann a professor of history living in Stilli, Switzerland. Leslie traveled to Stilli several years ago and visited the Baumann home.
There is a historic marker on the house and the translation text says: The home was built in 1730 by the married couple Kaspar Baumann and Anna Finsterwald. Built as a timber-framed house with a tiled roof. Behind the house, since about 1865, was a carpenter’s workshop, later a cooper’s workshop, today a model carpentry workshop.
Samuel and Maria Barbara Baumann arrived in New Orleans 18 May 1848. The town of Kenner would soon be established and would recruit families from Europe to purchase land in the newly developing town. Samuel purchased two lots and opened a large livery stable which was burned down by jealous competitors. Click here to read the excerpt from the book “An Untractable Country, The History of Kenner, Louisiana” by Craig A. Bauer. Craig describes Samuel and Barbara setting down roots in Louisiana. The community lost a staggering amount of people due to the yellow fever epidemic in 1853 including 2 of Barbara’s children. The photo below is Stilli, Switzerland.
________________________________________________________________
KENNER, LOUISIANA
I enjoyed reading Craig’s book about Kenner and learned a lot about the unforgiving land. The town is situated between the Mississippi River and Lake Pontchartrain, 30 minutes west of New Orleans. In the early 1700’s the first houses were being built and farmers were deciding which crops were best to raise. Indigo, rice and sugar cane seemed to do well however farmers were constantly battling flooding from the lake or the river and felt the strain of wondering which levee would fail next. William Kenner became one of the area’s wealthy settlers and had 3 large plantations which he would pass down to his children.
In the 1850’s the Great Northern Railroad laid track through Kenner. William Kenner’s two sons Philip Minor Kenner and William Butler Kenner thought it would be a good financial move to shift gears. They had given permission for part of the railroad track to be laid through one of their three plantations. The brothers thought it would be more profitable to build a town and sell plots of land rather than to continue farming. As time went on what was left of the plantations was held by Citizens Bank of Louisiana. The bank sold the land to John Deloss Rouse and James Connor Baumann. Maybe they bought the land at an auction. The men sold the land for $11,000.00 two months after they purchased it.
James became a very popular politician on the Republican ticket. He was an advocate for equal education for all the children in the community. The Baumann’s stayed in Kenner until December 5, 1891 when political enemies riddled the Baumann home with bullets. Click here to read an excerpt about James from the book “An Untractable Country, The History of Kenner, Louisiana”.
James was unable to escape the tentacles of politics in New Orleans. Click here to read an excerpt about his arrest in 1892. Again, this is scanned from the book “An Untractable Country”.
In New Orleans James became a real estate agent for a few years. In January 1900 he was appointed the Kenner county Shipping Commissioner. He was 67 when he retired in 1915. After retirement he moved to Los Angeles with Matilda where they passed away.
Click here to view papers typed by James Baumann of his Memoir. The pages are in sequence except page 10 and 11 which appear as the 2nd and 3rd page.
It’s been a great adventure taking a step back in time to see how our ancestors began life in this new country. Can’t wait to see where I Time Travel next.











Comments
thank you for your comment. It’s alway More...
Gemma was Auntie Phyllis' Godmother. More...
Such a beautiful story! Thank you for sh More...
Phyllis..... Thank You for Posting My Ph More...
Thank you to all who have posted. I wis More...